Orphan First Kill is a prequel to the 2009 film Orphan, both starring Isabelle Fuhrman as the main character Esther Albright / Leena Klammer. The prequel follows Leena Klammer, a 31-year-old psychiatric patient with a hormonal disorder called hypopituitarism that makes her look like a 9-year-old child. After running away from the institute by killing a guard and running away in someone’s car, Leena looks up missing American girls, and she realizes that she resembles one of the girls, Esther Albright. Leena poses as Esther and says her parents live in the U.S. The rest of the story is nothing short of a murder spree.
Now that this 13-year-late prequel is finally with viewers, it is time to enjoy movies like Orphan First Kill until another film comes out in the series. In fact, Isabelle Fuhrman already expressed her eagerness to play the character again, which should be an excellent pretext for the creators to come up with Orphan 3. Although we don’t think a 3rd film will not take another 13 years to make, we still know that it won’t come out tomorrow. So, we have lots of time in our hands to watch movies like Orphan First Kill that will give similar vibes.
The 1st film on our list of recommendations is Umma (2022), a supernatural horror film starring Sandra Oh as Amanda, a single mother living on an isolated farm with her daughter. Everything seems to be normal until the cremated ashes of Amanda’s mother, Umma, are given to Amanda by her uncle. While Amanda and her daughter Chrissy grapple with Umma’s ghost, Amanda also faces her childhood traumas, when her mother used to electrically shock her as a punishment.
2. The Unholy
You can also watch The Unholy (2021) until Orphan 3 arrives. The film has Jeffrey Dean Morgan playing a disgraced journalist called Gerry Fenn. Gerry’s job is to report all things that are unusual or strange. In the movie, his task takes him to a small town in Boston, where he experiences a series of divine miracles. As Gerry wants to use these events to resurrect his career, the miracles seem to come from a dark force with different plans.
3. No One Gets Out Alive
Another film on the movies like Orphan First Kill list is No One Gets Out Alive (2021), a Netflix horror film. The film follows Ambar, a young undocumented Mexican immigrant who moves into a boarding house after her mother dies. Right after she moves in, Ambar starts to experience weird dreams or events that she thinks are dreams. She sees ghostly figures and strange artifacts in the rooms of the house. She tries to run away, but she is trapped.
4. A House on the Bayou
A House on the Bayou (2021) is another horror film similar to Orphan First Kill. The film centers on the Chambers family, Jess Chambers, her husband John, and their daughter Anna. After Jess learns that John is having an affair with one of her students, the family goes on a vacation to a house in the Louisiana bayou. But everything goes awry when unexpected guests arrive at the house.
Separation (2021) is a supernatural horror film following a man named Jeff and his daughter Jenny after his wife dies in an accident. While Jeff tries to fight against his deceased wife’s father for Jenny’s custody, Jenny leads a life surrounded by puppets and frightening characters who come to life. However, the motives of these entities are much darker than beautiful Jenny expects, and the family is haunted.
6. The Lodge
The last film you can watch until Orphan 3 is The Lodge (2019). A psychological thriller just like Orphan First Kill, The Lodge follows a woman named Grace who is about to be the stepmother of her fiance’s 2 children, who recently lost their mother to suicide. When Grace becomes stranded with the children at a rural lodge, they experience several unexplained events related to Grace’s past. Grace was raised in an extremist Christian cult and was the sole survivor of mass suicide committed by the cult’s members, including her father.